Discussion about this post

User's avatar
CosmicJohn's avatar

It all has to do with the same thing. When they were trying to get a fast action and couldn't they could dream about one. When they finally got one they found most fly fishers don't know how to cast. So they sell them slow fly rods to cover their mistakes. But you can't say you need this rod because you can't cast. Instead they tell them why a technically unsound rod is the right thing to have.

I wrote a whole big thing about this a while ago.

https://cosmicjohn.substack.com/p/fly-rods-part-1?r=2vbokz

https://cosmicjohn.substack.com/p/fly-rods-part-2?r=2vbokz

Trev Sliwkanich's avatar

Two things I think are interesting:

1) in older advertising copy, a “dry fly action” was a crisp, light cane or glass rod whereas in today’s graphite market a “dry fly rod” is generally the slower or moderate actions

2) a never changing complaint it seems is that rods are being made “too stiff”. Ray Bergman’s “Trout” from the first half of the last century features a comment that many rods then were being made too stiff to be pleasant for fishing and required such heavy lines in order to bring out the action in casting that it was detrimental to fishing clear and shallow water.

Just too funny

No posts

Ready for more?